🔗 Share this article

As a critic, I've made enough mistakes to enjoy a sense of validation when an assessment proves correct. In the early 80s, I enthusiastically reported about a new Stephen Sondheim musical which I attended during its New York preview run. Panned by professional reviewers and rejected by theatergoers, the production shut down just two weeks after opening. In the 2023-24 season, the very same musical completed a twelve-month Broadway run, received four Tony recognitions and garnered critical acclaim.

The Journey of Reinvention

Although I mention "the very same musical," this isn't entirely true. Adapted from a Depression-era work by the legendary playwright duo, it remains the same story told in reverse chronological order. The narrative explores failing friendships centering around an ambitious musician turned film maker called Franklin Shepard. During the performance, he reminisces across his years and observes the slow dissolution of his artistic collaboration with dramatist Charley along with their shared bond with novelist Mary.

Production Changes

In the wake of the musical's poor reception in 1981, the composer and librettist implemented significant revisions. The show doesn't start with a student song written by Franklin but instead begins with a lavish gathering marketing his newest movie success. The actor recruitment process underwent transformation. The initial production's actors featured youthful actors who started by simulating older individuals and transitioned smoothly toward younger versions as the evening progressed. Current productions now standardly cast experienced performers who navigate different ages with minimal adjustments.

The strength of the storytelling lies in its ability to connect uniquely with each individual. As demonstrated in backwards-told stories, the production shows how life inevitably involves negotiations, adaptations and feelings of absence.

Sondheim's Creative Genius

This remarkable show showcases the composer subtly taking revenge against his detractors. One memorable scene when a theater impresario lectures the young main characters concerning the need to provide hummable melodies for theater audiences, adding the memorable line: "I will inform you if Strandever creates a popular work." The greatest contradiction exists because that Sondheim's creation itself contains multiple cherished compositions featuring Old Friends, Good Thing Going and the signature song that have become lasting earworms with dedicated viewers.

Actor Portrayals

Should there be a legitimate complaint against Merrily, it involves its protagonist Franklin being somewhat unsympathetic. Yet, in this production, the starring thespian intelligently portrays the character not as a self-obsessed antagonist but more as a fated naif who moves through existence repeatedly picking the simplest solution. The ensemble performers superbly represent the protagonist's unsatisfied emotional desires, while the most eye-catching performance comes from the actor portraying Charley, who provides the role both nervous tension and ardent conviction in art's power to better human experience.

Enduring Legacy

Whether Merrily itself accomplishes this improvement rests with spectators to subjectively judge. The featured version offers ongoing delight and clearly demonstrates specifically what made a notorious failure evolved into a palpable hit. The filmed performance of this praised interpretation gives theater lovers the possibility to witness this remarkable transformation firsthand.